Skip to content
Service-King

Knowledge baseRFID Technologies

RFID or barcodes? A comparison for stocktaking and check-outs

The code is good for consciously indicating one thing. UHF RFID helps when you need to quickly recognize many tagged items. In practice, both methods can work in one register.

Prepared by: Service-King teamPublished: Updated:

RFID tag and barcode on packaging.
Topic illustration · Service-King

The most important differences in everyday work

UHF RFID and barcode or QR code
CriterionBarcode/QR codeRFID UHF
How to readOptical: The code must be readable by a scanner or camera.Radio: No need to show every label.
Many piecesTypically sequential, targeted scanning of individual codes.Possible to read multiple tags in one session.
Choosing one thingNatural by pointing the device to a specific code.Need to control the zone to avoid adding adjacent things.
Operator equipmentCode reader or compatible phone for selected 2D codes.Compatible UHF reader and antenna.
Marking on metalThe code can be printed on a suitable permanent label.You need a marker selected for working on metal.
Implementation costUsually easier to start with few things.Additional equipment and tests; the benefit depends on the process.

This comparison applies UHF passive RFID, not all radio technologies. NFC requires a different way of working. The principles of UHF communication are described GS1 EPC Gen2 standard.

When the code is sufficient

If you're checking out several highly available items a day, the cost of UHF prep may be hard to justify on scan time alone. QR is also convenient when an employee has to open a machine's card by phone or deliberately confirm a specific item.

First, organize the IDs and circulation. Even the best code won't explain who the tool was released to if no one records the check-out. One item record should combine designation, location, history and relevant documents.

When to test UHF

  • You list many rooms, and a lot of your time is spent looking for labels.
  • You are counting sets or large batches of marked items.
  • Items often arrive in containers and require quick comparison against the list.
  • You want to check the compliance of the equipment with the records without copying the numbers.

UHF requires testing on real objects. Label visibility is not necessary, but material and positioning are still important. A metal shelf, liquids or tightly packed tools can change the reading efficiency.

A mixed solution is often the most practical

The condition is simple: both IDs must point to the correct item in the system. When replacing a label, do not accidentally create a second item. Also, make sure to distinguish between a product model and a specific item. The code of the same power screwdriver as a model does not automatically identify its individual pieces.

Calculate financial viability without promising a percentage

What to measure in a trial
MeasurementWhy you need it
Preparation and markingThis is the startup cost that is not visible in the scan time itself.
Full operation timeIncludes exception handling, identification, acknowledgment, and handling.
Differences requiring inspectionQuick reading does not help if the result needs to be corrected for a long time.
Working frequencyThe same equipment will pay off differently for the annual stocktake and daily check-outs.
Cost of equipment and maintenanceCompare the entire lifetime, not just the label price.

Use for your own assumptions time and ROI calculator. The model shows the value of time recovered, not automatic cash profit. The functions of the list are described on the website RFID stocktaking in Service-King.

Short selection checklist

  • Do you identify a model, a batch or an individual piece?
  • How many items do you check in one operation?
  • Are the codes easily accessible and legible?
  • Is the tag intended to work on metal, fabric or in difficult conditions?
  • Do you need a telephone, a handheld terminal or a fixed reading point?
  • Have you tested for the adjacent item to be incorrectly read and the correct item not to be read?

Discusses the selection of markings for tools tool marking guide. There is no need to replace the entire register to sensibly combine codes and RFID.

Sources and further verification

Back to the knowledge base

Website language

Choose a language.